Welcoming the Foreigner: Compassion, Discernment, and the Church

In America’s current polarized climate, even within the church, there is an ongoing debate surrounding sanctuary cities, the influx of undocumented immigrants, and how the church should respond. Many cities have seen partnerships between government agencies and churches to address this issue. However, the friction this has caused within the church reveals a deeper issue—a pressing need for discernment among believers.

For several years, Christians have debated the church's role in caring for undocumented immigrants, many of whom may not share the faith. A crucial question arises: “What is the most loving and Christlike response?”

Reflecting on Borders from a Biblical Perspective

When considering the debate over open borders and the role of the church in immigration, two primary questions emerge: Is an open-border policy biblical? And should the church assist in the care of undocumented immigrants?

1. Is an Open Border Biblical?

   The Bible does not endorse an open-border policy. In the Old Testament, borders were established for the nation of Israel. God clearly delineated Israel’s boundaries, instructing them to maintain their land as a distinct nation (Deuteronomy 32:8, Numbers 34:1-15). God’s design for Israel included physical boundaries to protect its people and preserve their unique identity. Likewise, the concept of borders is reflected in creation itself, as even heaven and earth have dividers (Genesis 1:6-7).

Moreover, Romans 13:1-2 instructs believers to respect governing authorities and the laws they establish. Governments are instituted by God to maintain order, and this instruction emphasizes honoring these authorities as long as they do not contradict God’s commands. Therefore, God's approval of borders implies that boundaries themselves are not unbiblical but serve a protective function.

1. The Call to Welcome the Foreigner: Is it Misinterpreted?

   A verse often cited in favor of a more open policy is the call to welcome the foreigner (Leviticus 19:33-34). However, this command is nuanced. Right after this instruction, we see examples where Israel defended its borders and identity, such as when Joshua, under God’s guidance, protected the land by driving out nations that would bring pagan practices (Joshua 6-12).

In context, the command to “welcome the foreigner” serves as a foreshadowing of the gospel, symbolizing Jesus' invitation to all people, regardless of origin, into the family of faith if they seek Him. This is exemplified in Rahab’s story (Joshua 2, Hebrews 11:31). Though a foreigner, Rahab was accepted and protected because of her faith in Israel’s God. This welcoming spirit aligns with Christ’s call to embrace all who seek Him (Matthew 25:35-40).

However, this command does not imply that believers should disregard national boundaries or laws. Rather, it reflects the church’s mission to welcome those whose hearts are open to God.

The Role of the Church: Discernment and Obedience to the Holy Spirit

Given the complexity of this issue, how should believers respond today? The church should refrain from aligning itself with governmental agendas on immigration, especially when these agendas do not uphold biblical values. The church’s mandate is to share the gospel, not to serve political objectives (2 Corinthians 6:14-15). When the government leads the church instead of the Holy Spirit, believers can become entangled in worldly pursuits, losing sight of their divine mission.

You may ask, “Where is the church’s compassion in this?” The church’s compassion and ongoing mission do not cease simply because we do not directly provide resources to those who come into our country. Our call is to go out into the world, not for the world to come to us. True compassion compels us to step out of our comfort zones so that others may find comfort. However, blanket support that does not lead people to God may merely serve to enjoy the resources of those who worship the one true God. This is not compassion; it is poor stewardship of what God has given us and merely servicing for the sake of servicing. This occurs when there is a lack of leading and guidance from the Holy Spirit.

Compassion requires discernment rather than unrestricted virtue signaling to one’s fellow man.

A Call for Discernment and Spiritual Clarity

Now more than ever, we need to draw near to the Holy Spirit, seeking clarity from God in these challenging times. John 16:13 reminds us that the Holy Spirit guides believers into all truth. If we are willing to listen, He will grant us wisdom to navigate these issues in ways that honor God’s commands.

While many perspectives exist, let us strive to be rooted in Scripture rather than political agendas. As we consider our response to immigration, we must prioritize the gospel, treating each person with respect and welcoming those who are open to faith while exercising wisdom in our actions. Let us move beyond our limited human understanding and lean on the teaching, conviction, and guidance of the Holy Spirit.