Policy vs. Character: A Christian Dilemma in Voting

As the upcoming election draws near, many Christians in the United States find themselves facing one of the most polarizing political seasons in recent memory. A key dilemma arises: should believers prioritize a candidate's policies or their personal character? Both present significant moral concerns, as we see candidates supporting policies that go against biblical teachings, while others exhibit personal character traits that clearly contradict God's standards.

The Tension Between Policy and Character

On one hand, certain policies in our nation stand in direct opposition to God’s Word. Issues like abortion, LGBTQ+ advocacy, and favoritism create communal corruption, challenging the biblical foundations of life, marriage, and justice. Policies like these reflect a broader societal stance that runs counter to the teachings of Christ. As a result, many argue that such policies, if left unchallenged, may lead to a nation turning away from God’s favor.

On the other hand, we see candidates whose personal lives are marred by moral failures—adultery, pride, dishonesty, and other character flaws. These issues are equally condemned by Scripture and stand as a public example of what it means to lead. When leaders exhibit poor character, they not only fail as moral role models but also risk leading the culture toward further moral decay. Some argue that personal integrity is the most important quality in leadership, as it shapes the moral tone of a nation.

Which is More Important: Policy or Character?

Both policy and character are critical. However, we must recognize that, in a fallen world, no candidate will perfectly embody biblical principles in both areas. It’s essential to discern which of the two takes precedence in a given election.

Those who prioritize character may argue that a leader’s personal life influences the culture. If a leader is dishonest or morally corrupt, they set a dangerous example for society. However, others may counter that policies are what truly shape a nation’s direction. Leaders who enact godly laws—protecting life, supporting biblical marriage, and upholding justice—can have a lasting impact, even if their personal lives fall short of Christian standards.

In the end, character is not always more important than policy. A leader who does not know Christ will likely not meet God’s standard for moral integrity. Moreover, a charismatic but deceptive leader could easily mislead the public. Conversely, policies that affirm God’s desires for justice, life, and righteousness in a nation may lead to societal blessing, even if the leader enacting them has personal failings.

Impartiality and Discernment

As followers of Christ, we are called to be impartial, just as God is. James 2:1 warns against showing favoritism, reminding us not to be swayed by external appearances or superficial moral displays. This is important when considering political candidates. Rather than favoring those who appear morally upright on the surface or those with charisma, we should strive to discern both their policies and character in light of Scripture.

It’s also vital to resist the temptation to align fully with a political party or ideology, as neither fully captures the heart of God’s will for His people. As Christians, we should be careful not to idolize political leaders or movements but to keep our focus on Christ’s teachings as our ultimate guide.

How Should Christians Vote?

Ultimately, both policy and character matter. Policies influence the direction of a nation, while character influences the culture and moral fabric of its people. But character influences the culture and moral fabric of its people as well as the policies. As voters, Christians must prayerfully weigh both, seeking God’s wisdom in making a decision that honors Him.

When faced with imperfect choices, it’s essential to prioritize the principles that align most closely with biblical teachings. This means considering not only the policies a candidate supports but also the integrity of their leadership. Through prayer, discernment, and a commitment to God's Word, believers can cast their votes in a way that reflects their faith and trust in God's sovereignty over all things.

However, when a candidate’s policies or character clearly contradict the teachings of Scripture—especially on issues that pertain to life, marriage, or justice—Christians have the freedom to reject those choices. In some cases, abstaining from voting for a flawed candidate can be a valid and responsible exercise of faith. Choosing not to cast a vote in such situations is a privilege that believers in this country can embrace when the available alternatives conflict with God’s will.